What I Learned About Planting Herbs Together

September 28, 2009

in Brooklyn,Herbs

Post image for What I Learned About Planting Herbs Together

I learned a good lesson about planting herbs together in the same container. It’s not best to do so. Similar to planting celery in the same container -- nothing horrible will happen, but the herbs won’t grow as well.

When I first planted them in my backyard vegetable garden in Brooklyn, the herbs were planted two to a container.

It just happened to work out that my grandmother had just enough containers to accommodate that, and I didn’t want to buy any more.

So they were planted based on what I thought tasted well together. Made perfect sense to me. Rosemary and thyme, chocolate and spearmint and so on.

The thyme totally dominated the container and the rosemary barely grew. While both of the mints grew, they got entangled and didn’t last too long.

I definitely think that the herbs would’ve done much better if they were planted in their own containers.

Another lesson learned and no one or thing was harmed.

What’s your experience with planting herbs together?

Related Posts with Thumbnails
  • SSanf
    Herbs grow all different sizes. So, yes, you are right to plant them in separate containers until you know what each one is about. What a lot of people do not know is that many herbs make very pretty flowers and can add beauty to the garden as well as giving you great flavorings for your cooking. But, watch out. Some grow like weeds and you may find you have a lot more than you bargained for.
  • Mike Lieberman
    Totally hoping for more than I bargained for this year.
  • Hi Mike - I think part of it is what you are trying to do. If you want something to be decorative and edible, sometimes overflowing and crowed really works. Also, some herbs like mint are just plain bullies and will take over any container. I really like rosemary and thyme together - but in a big pot or bag.
  • Mike Lieberman
    Cool. Got it. When I get my next round of plantings in will put in their own containers.

    This time around I planted together because of resources, but now realize that I have much more available like soda bottles, etc.

    Thanks for the advice.
  • tildentom
    when passing by construction sites get friendly with the laborers the can snag you empty compound buckets, easier to clean than paint buckets and works well for tree seedlings and herbs and tomatoes
  • Mike Lieberman
    I prefer to get mine from restaurants, delis or the bodegas. Don't have to worry about all the gunk that was in them beforehand.
  • You're exactly right about trial and error. I think the trick is to find compatible herbs--similar needs, compatible growing habits. Marydelle is right about herbs needing room. They will grow like mad. My wild and wooly herb bed: http://www.bumblebeeblog.com/photos/?album=24&photo=415
  • Mike Lieberman
    Thanks for the comment Robin. Totally jealous of your herb garden. What do you do with all of that? What do you have growing?
  • marydelle
    Either separate containter or larger ones. And, as you are learning, some are take-over herbs, while others will be dwarfed out. I think you've made a good lesson. Thanks for sharing it. Even having done this a while, I need to be reminded.
  • Mike Lieberman
    Thanks for the comment Mary. I just assumed rosemary and thyme grew together. This whole experience is about doing and sharing.
blog comments powered by Disqus

Previous post:

Next post: